Tuesday, 17 November 2026 Search Subscribe
Brighton Palace Pier stretching into the sea under a cloudy sky, seen from the water
Onthewings, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Coastguard agency asks where the line falls between pleasure and commercial vessels in a 12-week call for evidence

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency launched a 12-week call for evidence on Tuesday on how the definition of a pleasure vessel is understood and applied, an exercise prompted by the Marine Accident Investigation Branch report into a fatal incident off Cowes in October 2022, with responses due by 1 February 2027.

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency is asking mariners, owners, operators and other stakeholders how the legal definition of a pleasure vessel works in practice, in a 12-week call for evidence launched on Tuesday. The agency wants to hear whether the boundary between commercial and pleasure use is ever hard to draw in real operations, with responses due by 1 February 2027.

The distinction matters because it decides which safety rules apply to a vessel. The definitions of pleasure and commercial vessels determine different regulatory requirements covering lifesaving equipment, training, inspections and certification, so a boat that falls on the wrong side of the line may be operating under the wrong safety regime without its operator realising it.

Ferries, lorry parks and check-in lanes at the Port of Dover seen from above
Raimond Spekking, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Ferries and freight lanes at the Port of Dover. Commercial vessels face a different set of safety requirements on lifesaving equipment, training, inspections and certification from pleasure vessels.

The document published alongside the launch seeks views on three questions: how the definition works on the water from day to day, whether its wording still suits modern boating, and what misunderstandings surround the term. Responses can be submitted through the call for evidence page on GOV.UK or by email to the agency's codes team.

This is not a consultation on regulatory changes; this is a call for evidence, prompted by an important MAIB report.Esmé Flegg, Maritime and Coastguard Agency

The exercise has a sombre origin. It was prompted by a report from the Marine Accident Investigation Branch into an incident off Cowes, Isle of Wight, in October 2022, in which a crew member fell overboard from the Sonar class keelboat LimbItless while racing and died from the effects of immersion, despite wearing a correctly fitting lifejacket and appropriate sailing clothing. Her crewmates were unable to recover her from the water, and she could not be revived after being brought ashore.

A large blue and white installation vessel with tall jack-up legs moored at a quay
Vincent van Zeijst, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The wind turbine installation vessel MPI Resolution in port, its orange lifeboat visible on the stern. The Cowes investigation found a crew insufficiently practised in recovering a person overboard.

The investigators found that the activity's risk assessment was incomplete because it did not consider how a person who had fallen overboard would be recovered, and that the crew were insufficiently trained and practised in recovering a person overboard. The branch recommended that the agency revisit the definition so that it is clear that boats run by organisations and charities carrying vulnerable children and adults are not classed as pleasure vessels.

The agency is stressing that it is gathering evidence, not proposing new rules. Esmé Flegg, the agency's Innovative Technologies Lead for Code Vessels, said the agency wants to hear from a range of groups and individuals about how the definition is applied, whether there is ambiguity, and what influence it has on operations, adding that the evidence gathered will help the agency understand how the current definition operates as part of its work to keep all sectors safe on the water.

Filed under: Society, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, Sailing, Safety at sea, Cowes, MAIB

Corrections
None to date. The Journal corrects errors promptly and transparently. Read our corrections policy.
Daily Herald
Staff reports